Appendix A: TWIN SPRINGS ALLOTMENT Photo Field Notes-- Manti-La Sal National Forest

Date

Location

GPS

Photo #

Description

Oct 8 2005 (DK)

Boundary of Bears Ears and Twin Springs Allotment

4166700

601200

1603

Beyond fence is Twin Springs Allotment

4167300

601400

1606

Twin Springs Allotment taken from a cattle guard on Elk Ridge Road at turnoff to Woodenshoe Point

Forest Road 340 on way to Woodenshoe Point

595146

4170542

1608

Denuded spring

594970

4170709

1609

Another spring, originates to the right

595095

4171393

1616

Another spring near Forest Road 340

595029

4171424

1617

Another spring

595513

4170029

1638

Small meadow to the east of the road, below a cattle trough in background

595100

4182050

1644

Incised creekbed, downstream from Cooper Spring

1645

Sept. 4

2005

(MOB)

Just off Bears Ears Road on Short Point

0599825

4163444

1854

1855

Serviceberry browsed w/ no grass component -- bare earth. But no grasses under shrubs or trees

8,088'

0599968

4163262

1857

Browsed serviceberry w/ cow patty -- serviceberry is elected against in pinyon-juniper because it is preferred forage

1858

Short grazed grass

0600002

4163181

1859

Consistently bare ground; one scarlet gilia within a shrub.

0600075

4162788

1860

Bulldozed pond on Short Point: Dry. Prostate knotweed & red stem filaree on pond bottom (common invasive plants) D ense sagebrush at edge. Moss under trees, lichens inside P-J where cattle don't graze. Cliffrose and snowberry where sagebrush too dense for cattle.

Twin Springs

0598774

4170137

1861

Eutrophied pond, lower of the Twin Springs.

1862

Intermediate wheatgrass planted ; timothy, orchard grass; few forbs: Achillea, an aster, dandelion, gooseberry. Compacted ground around the pond; areas where prostrate knotweed

1864

Small frogs w/ 2 red lines vertically down their backs at the sides

1866

Exotic grasses surround the pond: Intermediate wheatgrass, orchardgrass, smooth brome, "redtop" Agrostis (?)

1868

Compacted soil at west side of pond

1869

Pounded area N of pond

8,545'

0598807

4170167

1870

1871

Incised inlet N end of spring -- just beyond fence -- 3 ½ - 4'

1872

Willow on the right being isolated from creek; creek is losing structural integrity

1874

Trampled spring water barely flowing into the pond below

1875

The second pond at Twin Springs

8,581'

0598812

4170240

1877

The upper pond of Twin Springs. One frog seen, while dozens in the lower pond

1879

Spring piped for pond; riparian area eliminated around the spring.

1880

Dead willows, west side of upper pond

1881

Dewatered wetlands -- willows dead, aspen falling down

1882

Willows are browsed as they try to come back

Upstream of Twin Springs

0598795

4170272

1883

1884

1885

1887

1888

The gooseberry cut and sprayed

Many were treated with herbicide, cut shrubs

1890

1891

Newly-dying willows. Dying this year

1892

Dying willows looking south Looking south

1893

Close up pf dying willows

Going up stream

0598796

4170310

1894

Dead willows

8,630'

0598820

4170419

1897

Willows dying

1898

1900

Mechanical cut of gooseberry. Horse poop in the swale. Hear horses upstream

8,644'

059825

4170506

1901

1902

1904

Another trough bathtub---log---beat out area

Further up from Twin Springs

8,735'

0598783

4170609

1905

Willows and aspen dying in swale; Gooseberry lopped off

1906

Willows being browsed as they try to resprout

Approx.

0598774

4170137

1908

2 locks -- 1 FS, 1 presumably permittee -- at lower pond

Caprock area up Road ­­­___

8,586'

0598544

4170135

1911

Bitterbrush browsed to ~3"---all browsed

1912

Pedestaled bunchgrass with moss in the tuft- bare ground surrounding

1913

Cow patties on the cap rock

1914

Intermediate wheatgrass planting

1915

Old snowberry pedestaled -- only a few leaves

1916

So little soil, still grazing---pedestaled bunchgrass

1917

Ky bluegrass. All shrubs heavily, heavily browsed

Aspen stand

8,589'

0598495

4170436

1919

Aspen stand w/ ponderosa in it---essentially no recruitment

1920

Browsed aspen and Kentucky bluegrass

1921

Aspen stand -- no recruitment. Practically no forbs. Snowberry essentially the only shrub

1922

Aspen repeatedly browsed -- 3" high

Across from the horse-grazed aspen, in the P-pine

8,588'

0598371

4170399

1925

Cow patties outside the aspen stand

1926

Bare dirt, logged P-pine, cow patties. Almost exclusively exotics: Kentucky bluegrass, bulbous bluegrass, timothy, smooth brome

1927

Aspen stand thin, scattered w/ P-pine

1928

Bare ground in aspen grove---mostly only snowberry. Occasional squirreltail

1929

Bare Ground in aspen stand.

Logging of P-pine---leaving essentially no down wood

1930

Intermediate wheatgrass seeding in aspen stand. Timothy and smooth brome also in the aspen stand Few other species in the stand.

8,630'

0598183

4170496

1931

Check dam cowed out and stinky. Mosquito larvae

0598067

4170498

1932

1933

Cows up road, grazing in a mostly bare area, an old landing. Early crested wheatgrass

1934

Bunchgrass clipped to ~1" , leaving seeded grasses less grazed

Cattle in a burn

8,736'

0597705

4171689

1936

Downslope in recent burn

1937

Eroded slope (burn)

1938

1939

1940

Cows in burn -- Ground about 80% bare

1941

Browsed grass on bare, eroding slopes

1942

Cows in the burn area

1945

Cow patties on bare ground.

Sagebrush slope further down the road

8,192'

0598534

4172890

1946

Cows in sagebrush

1947

Bare areas. with cow patty

1948

Close-cropped grass. Ky bluegrass, crested at 4"

1949

Eroding slope

1950

Cows

1951

Clipboard over 7" gully

1952

Grass component grazed out in sagebrush

1953

Crested wheatgrass basically surviving only under sagebrush

1954

Gambel oak surviving mainly only in sagebrush or under juniper. Gambel oak is heavily browsed

Further down the road

8,189'

0598254

4172972

1958

1964

Numerous cattle nearly at sunset, at edge of burn. Cows grazing on red clay slopes that have burned. Grasses ~1"-2" tall; sagebrush burned; beat out under ponderosa pine

Sept 5

Burn out on road to Woodenshoe Point

(MOB)

8,258'

0595848

4171342

1959

1972

Grasses mowed down in burned area

1960

Gambel oak browsed -- not much forage here aside from grasses

1961

1962

1965

1966

1967

1974

Grasses mowed---essentially no grass seed heads except on squirrel tail, which isn't being eaten

1970

1973

1976

Gambels oak browsed m

1975

Squirreltail not being eaten

1977

8" -- 9" bitterbrush old

Woodenshoe Point

8,364'

0595338

4172244

1982

Bitterbrush 3" tall (tallest 5)

Serviceberry ~ 11" browsed

Grasses 2-3 ½ " tall

8,422

0595386

4172325

1983

Grass seed heads 21" where rockier and down among brush

Across from burn in P-pine Forest

1985

Serviceberry browsed way back; serviceberry leaves seeing only inside browsed twigs. Grazing grasses to 1-2".